George Robinson

Who Really Dictates Salaries? Recruiters or Candidates?

By George Robinson

Recruiters are often accused of driving salaries up, inflating expectations and generally dictating what businesses need to pay to attract talent.

It's something we hear fairly regularly. But are recruiters really the ones setting the market rate?

The reality is that candidates have far more influence than they're often given credit for.

A pay rise isn't always enough anymore.

There was a time when offering someone a 10% salary increase was a fairly reliable way of getting their attention. If a candidate was earning £50,000, an opportunity at £55,000 could genuinely turn their head. Nowadays, it's rarely that straightforward.

Candidates are looking at the whole package and weighing up whether making a move is actually worthwhile. Salary, bonus, benefits, flexibility, career progression, travel and office expectations all play a part. And then there's everything that isn't necessarily reflected in a job description.

A good relationship with their manager. A business where they feel valued. A degree of autonomy. A team they enjoy working with. The security of knowing what they're walking into every morning.

If someone is happy, performing well and progressing in their current business, why would they take the risk of moving for an extra few thousand pounds?

It's not necessarily that candidates have become unreasonable about salary. It's that the financial incentive needs to justify what they might be giving up.

Recruiters can advise (but we can't dictate)

As recruiters, we have a pretty good view of what's happening in the market. We're speaking to businesses about their hiring plans and to candidates about their salaries, expectations and motivations every day.

That puts us in a position to offer informed advice about what a business might need to pay to attract the calibre of person they're looking for. But there's a difference between advising on salaries and dictating them.

If someone earning £65,000 tells us they wouldn't consider moving for less than £75,000, we haven't necessarily put that figure in their head. It's what they've decided would make a move worthwhile. We can talk through the opportunity, explain the benefits and challenge their expectations where appropriate. But ultimately, we can't tell someone what they should be willing to accept.

Sometimes businesses need to rethink what a role is worth

This is where things can become a little more challenging.

Businesses understandably have salary structures and budgets. They know what they've historically paid for certain positions and want to maintain consistency across their teams. But what a business paid for a role two or three years ago isn't necessarily what it will take to attract the right person today.

We see this in FMCG recruitment, particularly when businesses are looking for experienced sales and marketing professionals who can make a genuine commercial difference.

A strong National Account Manager with established retailer relationships, for example, could bring significant value to a business. Equally, an experienced marketing professional with the right category knowledge and commercial understanding could have a considerable impact.

If you find someone who ticks the boxes, has the experience you're looking for and could genuinely help move your business forward, is it worth losing them over a relatively small difference in salary?

Of course, that doesn't mean throwing budgets out of the window or paying whatever someone asks. Internal equity matters, and businesses need to make commercially sensible decisions.

But sometimes it means looking beyond what you've historically paid for a position and considering what that particular individual could bring to the business.

There's a difference between what a role has traditionally cost and what the right person might be worth.

So who actually sets the market rate?

Ultimately, it's a combination of what businesses are prepared to offer and what candidates are prepared to accept.

Recruiters sit somewhere in the middle, helping both sides understand what's realistic and where expectations might need adjusting.

We can share market insight, advise on salary benchmarking and explain why a particular package might not be attracting the right people. But we can't manufacture interest in an opportunity that simply isn't compelling enough.

And while businesses are perfectly entitled to decide what they want to pay, candidates are equally entitled to decide whether it's enough to persuade them to leave.

Businesses decide what they want to pay. Candidates decide whether it's worth moving for.

We think you might also like